The Doctor has strange tastes… but everyone can agree that this cake looks delicious, no matter where you’re from in the universe.

Not so, according to Reddit user Griffinburd, whose friend made the sweet time machine. Everything is edible (the Tardis itself is made from Rice Krispies) but apparently the “fondant tastes terrible,” forcing them to “treat it like we were peeling fruit to get to the cake.”

Still, we bet it tastes better than fish fingers and custard.